Y-Disciple's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Super Mario bros Z ep 5 (old series)]

Amazing

This is the finest piece of sprite work I've seen since MK vs. SF. It was incredibly animated and the fight scenes were packed to the brim with action that kept you interested. I can only dream that I'll be good enough to be compared to that. The reason I took off one point was because it seemed too anime-ish for NG and lacked the humor required to make me take any interest in the storyline. I found myself continuously hitting the spacebar and waiting for another fight scene to come. That and some voiceovers would have been nicer than having to read through it. Overall, this is an absolutely amazing piece of work and you should be extremely proud of what you are able to do. Keep up the excellent work and try to improve on the storyline a bit.

[Metal Gear: Untitled]

Hmm...

I wanted to give this a 2/5 for effort because you seemed to work hard on it, but I couldn't. This isn't NG worthy. Sorry. Remember to stay away from stick movies, make sure the plots make sense, make it a decent length, and add humor that's actually funny. Hope you can do better.

EB3 responds:

BLEH

[Shao Kahn Party]

Very good.

It was creative, well-animated, and quite funny. I liked the subway scenes and when they were running around the globe. Great use of the sprites. The only things I didn't like was that it wasn't quite as funny and original as some other MK movies here, and voice acting would have been nice. Overall, great job. Hope you make another one like this.

[Navy Recruiting Ad]

Already seen it.

I saw this before on another site, and I laughed my head off. However, this kinda ruined it for me. It was sloppily thrown together with just a navy guy and random pictures you found in 20 minutes, which is about half as long as it probably took to make this. I don't mean to flame you or anything, but I feel that you should have just left the fake ad alone rather than edit it to make it less funny. And were you the one that actually made the audio, or did you just take it from that other guy? If you were the one that made it, I'll feel a little better to know you didn't steal it or anything.

[Dumbass Luigi]

I thought it was stupid.

I didn't laugh at all. The jokes were pretty much all stale IMO and had been used several times before. The animation was great, so that's where you exceeded expectations, but as for content, you could have done much, much better. The part with the ugly baby song was utterly pointless and made me drop my head on my desk. I don't know why I hate it so much, since you did a good job overall. I guess it's just opinion.

[Throwback the Duck Ep. 0]

Pretty good.

The art and animation were amazing, but I found myself falling asleep watching it. It was quite boring and way too long. It wasn't very funny, so as a movie, it wasn't as entertaining as high-scoring NG movies like Animator vs. Animation. It's not something I would see more than once or twice. However, since this was just a backstory, I have a good feeling that the rest of the series will be much better and more entertaining. This does have a lot of potential and I was impressed for the most part. If you make your episodes shorter and to the point, I think you'll do really well. Good luck.

[Star Wars Special Edition]

Pretty good.

I really liked this. The actual art and animation weren't that good, and the sounds were kinda fuzzy, but the humor made up for that. I was laughing throughout the movie, especially at the part with the ID and Leia's message. Keep going with this.

[smoke rescue scorpion]

Damn, dude.

This was awesome! The sprite work was just about perfect, and the fight scenes were really cool. The only thing wrong was the sound effects. More MK animations should be like this. This deserves a much higher score and more recognition.